Another Dorfman clue is variations of "Eeeyowww" and "Yowww," whereas Paul S. Newman mostly sticks to a succint "Oww!" In Binder's Broken Arrow issue we find an "Ukkk!"
BROKEN ARROW
| Nov/57 | #855 | Apache Dowry | Otto Binder |
| Kingdom of Terror | Binder | ||
| Nov/58 | #947 | Desert Ordeal | Leo Dorfman |
| Vengeance Trail | Dorfman | ||
| Trackdown | Dorfman |
CHEYENNE written by Leo Dorfman
(other issues written by Paul S. Newman)
| May-July/58 | #7 | The Mustang Trail |
| Last of the Buffalo | ||
| Aug-Oct/ | #8 | Devil's Canyon |
| The Conspirators | ||
| Nov-Jan/59 | #9 | Manhunt |
| Trouble in Peace Valley | ||
| Feb-Apr/ | #10 | Gunpowder Pass |
| The Ghost Trail | ||
| May-July/ | #11 | The Rio Smugglers |
| The Crooked Circle |
GUNSMOKE written by Dorfman
(other Dell and Gold Key issues written by Newman)
| Feb-Mar/58 | #7 | Showdown |
| The Maverick | ||
| Apr-May/ | #8 | The Taming of Bull Halloran |
| Six-Gun Fury | ||
| June-July/ | #9 | Man Without a Gun |
| The Bounty Hunter | ||
| Aug-Sep/ | #10 | The Deadly Dude |
| Badge of Honor |
According to the GCD, Cheyenne #7 was written by Newman, and confirmed by Newman's own records.
ReplyDeleteEven when I set myself to searching out the evidence of Newman's work on those two stories, I can't find it--I looked again just now. Up through #6, and from #12 on, invariably there are his typical "He-help" or "He-hey" and very often his ricocheting gunshots Zing! Ping!--but not an instance of such things in #7. So in this case I'll leave the post as is, and acknowledge here that the GCD's pass-along of Newman's records and my takeaway from the stories themselves arrive at opposite conclusions.
ReplyDelete